Fail Safe vs Fail Secure: Which Door Default Your Building Needs
Fail safe and fail secure decide how a door behaves on the secure side during a power loss. Here is how to choose each opening without trapping anyone inside.
Fail safe unlocks the access-controlled side of a door when power is removed. Fail secure keeps that side locked. Neither setting should trap people inside. The exit side must still provide code-compliant egress. Choose the fail state for each opening, not once for the entire building.
An advisory deck does not prove a door works. A documented power-loss test does. Before approving the hardware, confirm what each door must do under the locally adopted code and assign someone to verify it.
Which side of the door does the fail state describe?
The fail state describes the secure side, where access is controlled. It does not describe whether occupants can leave. Require the contractor to name that side on the door schedule instead of writing “fail secure” without explaining what remains locked.
What fail safe does
Power keeps fail safe hardware locked. Remove power and the secure side unlocks. A magnetic lock works this way because electricity holds its armature against the magnet. Fail safe electromechanical locks also serve stairwell re-entry doors where required by the approved design.
What fail secure does
Power unlocks fail secure hardware. Remove power and the secure side stays locked. Electric strikes are commonly specified this way, though configurable models can support either setting. Check the installed configuration rather than assuming the product family tells you how the door behaves.
Is the opening on an exit route?
Start with how occupants get out. NFPA 101, the Life Safety Code, generally requires egress doors to open without special knowledge or effort, a point Learn Security Management makes in its CISSP guide on fail safe and fail secure. That does not mean every access-controlled exit door must unlock from the outside during an outage.
A fail secure electric strike can keep outsiders out while independent mechanical hardware lets occupants leave.
A magnetic lock that holds the door closed needs the release arrangements required for that locking system. Confirm the applicable requirements with the authority having jurisdiction, usually the building official or fire marshal.
Texas jurisdictions adopt code editions locally. Get the governing edition in writing before assuming the newest model code applies to your building.
Is it a stairwell re-entry door?
Leaving a floor for the stairs and getting back onto a floor are separate functions. Stairwell re-entry locks control the second one. A building can correctly use fail secure exterior entries and fail safe stair-side hardware.
Lori Greene’s I Dig Hardware guidance, updated for the 2024 International Codes, describes stairwell unlocking requirements tied to emergency release signals and fire alarm activation in an area served by the stairwell. Fail safe electromechanical locks allow the stair-side lever to unlock when power is removed.
Flag these doors separately on the schedule. Ask the fire marshal which re-entry and release requirements apply to your building before specifying the lock.
Is it a fire-rated door assembly?
A fire-rated door must retain its required latching function. Greene’s guidance explains that NFPA 80, Standard for Fire Doors and Other Opening Protectives, requires fail secure electric strikes on fire door assemblies, with strikes listed for that use.
Check the listing against the actual assembly, not just a catalog description. If a contractor cannot provide the applicable listing for a proposed strike, reject that selection before submittal. A fail secure setting alone does not establish compliance.
Does a perimeter or asset door need fail secure?
Fail secure is often appropriate where an outage should not grant access from outside. An exterior entry or equipment room still needs an approved design that preserves required egress. Protecting equipment never justifies trapping an occupant.
For openings where the code permits a choice, record the exposure behind the decision. An unlocked equipment room creates a different risk from a locked stairwell re-entry door. The door schedule should explain that distinction.
Perimeter and entry doors
Confirm that inside hardware operates independently of the electric strike. A lever or panic device should provide the required mechanical exit function even when the access-control system has no power. Test that function with the door closed and latched.
Magnetic locks and electric strikes
A proposal that names only “maglock” or “electric strike” is incomplete. Require the specific device and its installed fail state, along with the required release arrangement. The reviewer needs to know what the opening does, not just what hardware is being purchased.
How do power outages and storms change the answer?
For a Fort Worth-area facility, storm-related power loss belongs in the operating plan. Plan for an outage that outlasts the access-control batteries. Otherwise, you have reviewed normal operation but left the actual power-loss condition untested.
Why battery backup does not change the answer
Battery backup delays the fail state. It does not change it. When backup power is exhausted, the hardware takes its specified power-loss state. Required alarm releases must still operate according to the approved design while backup power is available.
Planning for an outage longer than the battery
Document what happens after backup power ends, including which entrances remain usable for authorized access. Assign responsibility for managing access during the outage. Do not rely on propping a rated door open as an improvised operating plan.
How do you test each opening before the inspector arrives?
Have qualified personnel coordinate the test with facilities and any affected monitoring provider. Removing power from access-control equipment can affect occupied areas. Test the opening against its approved design:
- Write down the expected behavior on each side before testing.
- Remove power at the appropriate supply under a controlled test plan. Account for battery backup rather than merely disconnecting utility power.
- Check access from both sides and verify the required inside release. Have qualified personnel test alarm-triggered releases separately where required.
- Date and sign the test record. Record any failure against the expected behavior.
After testing, restore the system and verify normal operation. Keep unresolved defects open until someone confirms the correction.
Who owns the door schedule and the test record?
Name the person authorized to approve the schedule and accept unresolved risk. That person needs the test records, not just the installation invoice. A door schedule without an accountable owner is an unfinished security design.
Access controllers also need change control. Assign approval authority for configuration changes and vendor remote access so a later software change does not quietly alter the approved operation.
Our Virtual CSO program provides executive security leadership across physical and digital risk, with reporting to the board. We run the program across all 13 risk domains rather than leaving leadership with an assessment and no program owner.
What should you confirm with the fire marshal before the inspection?
For regulated openings, the hardware catalog does not decide compliance. Ask the fire marshal or building official to review the proposed operation against the adopted code and approved plans. Resolve these points before submittal:
- The governing building and fire code editions.
- The required egress and release behavior for each affected opening.
- Stairwell re-entry requirements and emergency release signals.
- The applicable listing for each fire-rated assembly using an electric strike.
- The expected acceptance testing and documentation.
Keep written interpretations with the project record. They give the designer, installer and inspector a common basis for reviewing the opening.
If nobody owns these decisions across your facilities, book a 30-minute Risk Discussion to discuss virtual security leadership for your organization.
Frequently asked questions
Is a maglock fail safe or fail secure?
A magnetic lock is fail safe. Electrical power holds the armature against the magnet, so removing power releases the lock. Its installation must also include the release arrangements required by the locally adopted code.
Can an electric strike be changed from fail secure to fail safe?
Some electric strikes allow that change; others do not. Check the specific model’s instructions and listing before changing its configuration. For a fire-rated assembly, the strike must meet the applicable fail secure and listing requirements, so do not treat this as a routine settings change.
Does battery backup mean the fail state never matters?
No. Backup power postpones the power-loss state until the battery is exhausted. Test the opening with all relevant power sources accounted for, and separately verify any required alarm release.
Is fail secure dangerous in a fire?
Fail secure does not inherently prevent escape. A fail secure strike can keep the access side locked while independent mechanical hardware lets occupants exit. The complete opening must satisfy its applicable egress requirements and approved design.
Do I need a written interpretation from the building official?
Confirm the governing code edition and the required behavior for each affected opening, including stairwell re-entry. Review fire-rated hardware listings and acceptance-test requirements before submittal. Keep the written interpretation with the door schedule and test records.
Total 360 Security provides virtual Chief Security Officer, vCISO, and Enterprise Security Risk Management programs for mid-market organizations. They design, run, and report security programs covering all 13 risk domains rather than just offering advisory decks or point solutions. The firm is Texas DPS-licensed with CPP, CISSP, and CISM credentials.
Serving Texas, California, Nevada, New Mexico.
More from the blog
10 min read
Identity Access Management Software: What to Govern First
A practical order for identity access management software: define privileged access, name an owner, inventory raw exports and review each quarter before buying a tool.
Read article7 min read
SOC 2 Audit: What Type II Requires and Who Owns Each Control
A SOC 2 audit is an independent CPA examination of your controls against the AICPA criteria. Here is what a Type II report requires, who owns each control and what evidence to keep.
Read article7 min read
Compliance Monitoring: What to Check Monthly and Quarterly
Compliance monitoring is the ongoing check that your operations follow the rules that apply to you. This guide sets a monthly evidence set, a quarterly sampling routine and clear ownership for every exception.
Read article